Dzhon luag, "Ntawv Siv". Cov phau ntawv, uas xyuas tov

Qhov no lub caij ntuj sov, nyob rau hauv cov yeeb yam yog lwm premiere ntawm Dzhona Grina bestseller "Ntawv Siv". Phau ntawv txheeb xyuas tau muaj ib tug heev mixed: ib txhia twb hu nkauj nws praises, lwm leej lwm tus tau sib cav hais tias nws yog ib tug thib ob-rate ntaub ntawv, tsim los rau cov hluas, thiab lub ntsiab tob tob nyob rau hauv nws ntau tshaj li far-fetched. Needless hais, tias tom qab qhov kev txiav txim ntawm cov zaj duab xis yog heev uas zoo sib xws? Ntxiv tsuas thuam ntawm lub lam ntawm qhov kev ua si, thiab tus kiv cua 'kev xav tau muab faib rau cov "nws yog ci ntsa iab" thiab yas "tsis yog nyob rau hauv cov phau ntawv." Tom qab qhov kawg tshwj xeeb kev txaus siab yog cov nqe lus nug ntawm seb, thiab yuav ua li cas nws yog nyob rau hauv cov phau ntawv. Yog nws muaj tseeb hais tias Dzhon luag sau ib yam dab tsi zoo heev nyob rau hauv cov kab? Tom qab tag nrho, cov neeg ntes tau ib yam dab tsi ntawm phau ntawv no.

Yuav ua li cas phau ntawv "Ntawv Siv"?

Guest phau ntawv, raws li tau hais tias, yog heev ua kev. Nyob rau lawv nws yog ib qhov nyuaj los qhia rau dab tsi twb mus nyob rau hauv lub nrov tshiab. Txhua tam sim no thiab ces flashed lub npe tswvyim nrog Margo Roth Spiegelman, tab sis lub ruam tsis to taub dab tsi tus kiv cua hais tias "Ntawv Siv". Nws yog ib nqi qhia me ntsis zaj dabneeg.

zaj dabneeg

Lub tsev kawm ntawv cov menyuam kawm ntawv kawm kom tiav thiab yuav luag Kew Jacobsen thiab "huab tais ntawm lub tsev kawm ntawv," Margo Roth Spiegelman - cov neeg nyob ze. Raws li ib tug me nyuam, lawv feem ntau taug kev thiab cov phooj ywg. Tab sis raws li lawv loj hlob laus lawv xav tau ua ntau muab faib: twj ywm, ceev faj thiab Kew nyob tsis tswm Margot, rau cov uas muaj muaj tsis muaj kev txwv los yog teeb meem. Nyob rau ntawm ib tug taw tes, lawv paths diverged tsuas - tsis muaj quarrels thiab kev tsis sib haum, nws cia li tshwm sim. Ntau xyoo dhau los, thiab Margo Roth Spiegelman los ua ib tug neeg uas yuav tsis tau ignored, thiab Kew los ua (los yog?) Cia li ib tug neeg txawv, nyob rau hauv kev hlub nrog nws "huab tais" ntawm lub pob ntseg.

Yuav ua li cas yog lub qhov kawg nkaus?

Muaj ib hmo Margot nce tawm tau hauv lub qhov rais mus Kew thiab muaj yuav ua rau lub feem ntau zoo kawg taug txuj kev nyuaj ntawm nws lub neej - los rau txim rau thiab noj kua zaub ntsuab rau tus uas tsim txom. Ib ob peb ntawm kuj zoo kawg ua rau nws foray mus rau hauv lub hmo ntuj thiab xaus rau lub siab tshaj plaws pem teb ntawm lub tsev nyob rau hauv lub nroog ntawm High luminance, qhov twg Margo Roth Spiegelman, nyob rau hauv qhov tseeb, hais tias tus naas ej kab lus, uas tau muab rau lub npe ntawm phau ntawv - "Ntawv Siv". Phau Ntawv xyuas rau lawv no qhov teeb meem, raws li peb yuav tsum tau, contradictory: muaj cov neeg uas qhuas no: "ib daim ntawv nroog ... ntawv cov neeg nyob rau hauv daim ntawv lub tsev nyob", thiab muaj cov neeg uas hais tias yog xwb qhov no tus sau, Dzhon luag xwb kuv muab nws cim ib tug me ntsis pathos, thiab nws txoj kev txawj ntse, thiab kev txawj ntse ntawm cov phau ntawv nws tus kheej tsis yog hais tias.

Lub culmination ntawm tias tom ntej no thaum sawv ntxov Margo Roth Spiegelman disappears. Tab sis Knight Kew Jacobsen txiav txim siab mus nrhiav nws nobly. Yuav ua li cas nws tag nrho cov hnub, yuav qhia rau hauv phau ntawv nws tus kheej "Ntawv Siv".

Xyuas

Phau Ntawv Dzhona Maykla Green tus zajlus, nyob rau hauv tus touches - nws muaj intrigue, li ntawd tsim nyog kom tus nyeem ntawv yog tsis bored. Curious cim. Ob peb funny txhawb cim. Cov ntaubntawv mus rau ib tug paub qab hau lub tswv yim.

Yuav ua li cas hais txog tag nrho cov no xav nyeem ntawv?

Phau Ntawv xyuas daim ntawv ntawm lub nroog hais tias phau ntawv yog zoo rau contingent rau cov uas nws tau sau: lub tsev kawm ntawv uas muaj hnub nyoog hluas Tuaj mus saj thiab kev lom zem tso rau ntawm qhov chaw thiab ib tug ob peb naïve teeb meem no, tsab txawj nyeem ntawv laus.

Ntau mloog yog them mus rau lub reviewers, tus sau tau ua lub tsev lub finale. Nws yuav xyuam xim hu ua qhib: Dzhon luag tsis muab direct cov lus nug, nws yog xav-provoking, thiab teb tus nyeem ntawv yuav nthuav kom pom nws tus kheej.

Xws li ib tug style yog tsis ib tug neeg txawv rau Green: zoo li ntawd cai nyob rau hauv ib tug tsawg zoo-paub tias "Nrhiav rau Alaska".

meej mom

"Ntawv Siv" - ib phau ntawv, nyeem xyuas txog tej uas tsawg kawg mas ntawm lub chaw ua hauj lwm nws tus kheej. Nws zoo yog hu ua yooj yim style - phau ntawv no yog ib qho yooj yim, nws yuav tsum tau nyeem rau hauv lub hmo ntuj thiab twb txaus siab nrog xws li ib tug tseem ceeb cov khoom vaj khoom tsev. Thiab rau lub meej mom ntawm kev noj zoo kev lom zem, uas, incidentally, abound, nezaezzhennoy zajlus. Nws yeej muaj tseeb: nyob rau hauv lub "Ntawv Siv" tsis muaj cliché rau tsis muaj kev tshwm sim, los yog nyob rau hauv lub cim, uas yog heev pleasing. Nws yog kawm prose, thiab cov tub ntxhais sau phau ntawv no tej zaum kuj tsis yooj yim rau refrain los ntawm kev siv lub sij hawm mus soj ntsuam.

shortcomings

Tu siab, qhov zoo ntawm cov uas muaj xws li raws li yog haum rau lub tub hluas ntxhais hluas cov neeg tuaj saib, nws yog txo mus rau qhov no tsis muaj peev xwm - ib tug nqaim pawg hnub nyoog. Yau txawj nyeem ntawv Dzhona Maykla Ntsuab phau ntawv "Ntawv Siv" thiab noo nrog neeg laus cov txheej xwm, lawv yuav tsis to taub nws, rau cov neeg laus nws yog naive thiab ingenuous. Nws kuj ua rau tsis thwj ib theem zuj zus ntawm cov txheej xwm, thiab lub caij rau coj txawv txawv cwj pwm ntawm cov cim.

Nyob rau nruab nrab, cov phau ntawv muab ib tug kwv yees ntawm 6-7 tawm ntawm ib tug ua tau kaum.

zoo views

Muaj ntau nyeem "Ntawv Siv" tom qab tus naas ej "Txhaum nyob rau hauv Peb Lub Hnub Qub" thiab tau txais ib yam nkaus tiag tiag li impressions, txawm tias phau ntawv no, nyob rau hauv qhov tseeb, sib txawv. Rave kev xyuas feem ntau raws kev coj mus Margo Roth Spiegelman - ib tug txawv txawv cim nyob rau hauv sib piv rau qhov no txhua hnub Kew Jacobson. Txawj nyeem ntawv hais tias cov phau ntawv no yog zoo tagnrho rau cov kiv cua ntawm romance, taug txuj kev nyuaj thiab detective novels.

Tsis muaj zem hais tias muaj ntau ntawm cov kiv cua "Lub zos" - cov ntxhais. Lawv nyiam nws vim hais tias ntawm lub allergic thiab philosophical overtones. Cov neeg uas hlub puzzles, lawv kaj siab lug txais thiab innuendo nyob rau hauv lub kawg.

Nyob rau hauv peb vwm ntiaj teb no ntawm ceev mus rau lub pluses muaj xws li cov khoom thiab nws me me volume. Nws tacos hais ib co kev xyuas.

"Ntawv Siv" (Dzhon luag) - phau ntawv nrov heev, yog li kev xyuas thiab kev xav txog nws tau raug teem. Txawj nyeem ntawv hais tias cov phau ntawv yuav tsum tau hu ua zoo heev, nws ua rau koj xav txog cov kev sib raug zoo rau lawv hlub, mus rau lub ntiaj teb no, mus rau lub hais tsis zoo stereotypical cai ntawm cov haiv neeg.

Cov kev ncaj ncees ntawm zaj dab neeg yog ...

Muaj ib co yooj yim cov lus xaus uas tuaj mus rau lub fore tom qab nyeem cov phau ntawv.

Ua ntej ntawm tag nrho cov, ib tug uas teev nws tus kheej Margo Roth Spiegelman, hais txog nws tus cwj pwm - nws hu tag nrho cov ntawv, thiab cov kev nyeem ntawv xav tias: tej zaum yuav muaj tseeb daim ntawv? Tej zaum nws - daim ntawv?

Secondly, ib tug uas tshwm sim tam sim ntawd tom qab lub finals: lub stereotypes, dab tsi yog lawv? Yuav ua li cas lub moj khaum uas peb twb tau txo hwj chim? Tej zaum nws yog lub sij hawm cia mus ntawm cov neeg ruam kev cai?

Peb, yog ib tug uas zoo nkaus li tom qab ib co deliberation tshaj cov khoom "Ntawv Siv" (Dzhon luag). Xyuas hauv phau ntawv tsis yeej ib txwm coj mus rau hauv tus account qhov no xaus. Thiab nws yog li no: Yog hais tias koj khiav ceev, khiav tseem yuav tsis ua hauj lwm. Yog Margot los yog kev khiav sai li sai tau rau ib tug neeg laus (nyob rau hauv nws cov kev nkag siab) versions ntawm lawv tus kheej ntau tshaj ruam? Nws puas tsim ua ke tsis yog nrov nrog nws illusions ntawm lub ntiaj teb no lawv tus kheej, uas yog tiag tiag tsis muaj zoo dua?

Plaub, ib tug neeg yog cov tsawg kawg yog hnov xyuas: qhov teeb meem ntawm idealizing duab ntawm "huab tais" Margo Roth Spiegelman. Nyob rau hauv nws tej mlom vozvodid Quentin (Kew) Jacobsen, mus rau tib attribute thiab nws cov kiv cua "Ntawv Siv". Qhov no yog tsis ncaj ncees lawm, vim hais tias cov neeg sau nws tus kheej cov ntsiab lus tawm nyob rau hauv lub finale, yuav ua li cas ib qho tseem ceeb nws yog tsis mus saib tau cov duab ntawm tus txiv neej, tsim nyob rau hauv nws lub siab, thiab ua kom paub qhov tseeb essence. Hlub tseeb yog yeej ib txwm yooj yim, muab lub cim los ntawm txawm qualities. Ib hom ntawm tagnrho. Ib tug teeb meem ntawm xws li ib illusory kev hlub, uas yog ib qho tseem ceeb, yog ib qho tseem ceeb tsis tau tsuas yog rau cov hluas, tab sis kuj nyob rau hauv adulthood. Thiab qhov ntau cov neeg tshaj, li ntawd, heev rau nws muab li tus cwj pwm.

tsis zoo tswvyim

Lub intricacies ntawm ib qho yooj yim thiab tsis yooj yim, uas tsis yog-qhov tseem ceeb thiab loj heev - uas rau hauv phau ntawv "Ntawv Siv". Xyuas nws muaj tsis tau tsuas yog qhov zoo. Cov neeg uas ua hauj lwm tsis sunk rau hauv tus ntsuj plig nyob rau hauv nws txaus shortcomings.

Nws yog liam tias txawm lub fact tias Dzhona Grina phau ntawv hu ua "lub neej", tab sis nyob rau hauv kev muaj tiag lawv yog cov tsis. Margot heev zoo meej, ib yam nkaus thiab zoo tib yam Quentin.

Lub ntsiab lus nyob rau hauv lub chaw ua hauj lwm overlaps heev trite thiab hais lus phem tham cov phooj ywg, comrades, hais tias tsis zoo li xav tias txaj muag thiab gram rau hais tias tej yam uas.

Cov zajlus nws thiaj li tsis meej pem li ntawd zaum kawg tawm tsis yog li ntawd ntau npaum li cas qhib thiab unsaid, raws li unconvincing. Lub cim yuav tsum tsis txhob zoo correlated nrog tus nyeem ntawv, tab sis nws yuav tsum tau sau ib daim ntawv li ntawd hais tias cov kev xaiv ntawm tus hero yuav tsum to taub, txawm yog tias txhua leej txhua tus lwm tus nyob rau hauv nws cov hauj lwm cia li tsis tau paub thiab txais tsis tau tejyam. Qhov no ua hauj lwm lub teeb ntsuab suab ua tsis tau tejyam.

Raws li rau lub suab rau tus sau kuj pab leg ntaubntawv tshwm sim. "Ntawv Siv" - ib phau ntawv uas xyuas txog uas ib txwm pib nrog, raws li tus sau sau. Thiab tsis txhua leej txhua tus zoo siab nrog nws yooj yim style. Nyob rau hauv tas li ntawd, ib txhia complained hais tias nyob rau hauv nruab nrab ntawm cov khoom es tsis txhob ua spectacular, nws yuav monotonous thiab boring. Qhov no ua tim khawv rau qhov tseeb hais tias Dzhon luag ua tsis tau tejyam ua kom txoj kev hloov los ntawm me me mus rau mob loj heev ntse.

Yog muaj ib tug kev pom?

Tu siab, tsis muaj, muaj yog tsis muaj kev pom zoo. Phau ntawv "Ntawv Siv" (Dzhon luag) neeg xyuas piav qhia txog heev tsis meej xwm. Raws li ib txwm: ib tug neeg tug txiv qaub, uas thawv tawm ntawm txiv qaub. Thiab txhua uas txo nws hwj "Ntawv Siv" rau ntawm lub thaj muaj ib tug neeg uas xav kom muab nws pov tseg thiab tau unsubscribe lub sij hawm thiab nyiaj txiag siv nyob rau hauv vain. Zoo, uas tau tsim lawv tus kheej lub tswv yim, nws yog tsim nyog nws cia li mus nyeem!