Pussy Riot, Tsab ntawv ntawm kab lis kev cai

DAB TSI kos npe rau "neeg ua hauj lwm ntawm Culture"?

Yog li ntawd, muaj lwm tseem ceeb tshwm sim nyob rau hauv peb "kev cai" lub neej. Ntau tshaj ib puas "kev cai" thiab okolokulturnyh nuj nqis kos npe rau ib tsab ntawv nrog ib cov xav kom tso tawm "cov yaj uas ploj lawm" ntawm cov pab pawg neeg nrog rau cov kev phem lub npe ntawm "Pussy Riot" los ntawm lub dungeons, qhov uas lawv tsis tau tso, vim hais tias lawv (cov thawj coj) ntseeg tau hais tias lawv tsis tau cog lus dab tsi txhaum, tab sis tsuas yog "hu nkauj thiab thov Vajtswv" nyob rau hauv lub qhov chaw, uas yog nyob rau hauv lub tuam tsev. Txhua yam mus - thiab "txoj kev hlub tshua rau cov poob", thiab hu rau txoj kev khuv leej rau cov "txom nyem hluas nkauj", uas dhau li ntawm muaj cov me nyuam txom nyem los ntawm qhov uas tsis muaj leej niam.

Mas muaj pes tsawg leeg ntawm cov nuj nqis. Qhov loj cov npe ntawm cov txuj ci los yog tsuas yog zag ntxias yuav ntaus rau lub zog ntawm ib tug ib nrab los yog ob lub kaum os, lwm leej lwm tus tau hais khov kho hu lawv tus kheej directors, hu nkauj, lam, musicians thiab lwm tus neeg, uas kab lis kev cai yog tsis ntau tshaj li lub sij hawm nrog vague ntaem, tab sis ua li cas koj xav kom qhia lawv tus kheej thiab sawv ntawm cov nrov nrov npe, tej zaum, thiab ua li cas cov kev pab cuam yuav tsum, thiab yog dab tsi ib tug yog vim li cas - nws tsis txawv.

Ntawv central Tenet yog:

"Tus hluas nkauj tua tsis muaj ib tug, tsis robbed, tsis ua nruj ua tsiv, tsis rhuav tshem thiab nyiag lwm tus neeg tej khoom vaj tse. Zog ntawm Guj kuj - ib tug secular hauv lub xeev, thiab tsis muaj anti-clerical kev ua yog hais tias lawv tsis txhob poob nyob rau hauv tsab xov xwm ntawm lub txim txhaum Code, tsis tau yog vim li cas rau criminal foob. "

Thiab ntawm no yog koj yog yuam kev, gentlemen. Kev nruj kev tsiv lawm, thiab tej zaum nws yuav tsis tau yuav lub cev. Kev nruj kev tsiv tiv thaiv sab ntsuj plig ntau npaum li cas txaus ntxub muab, thiab lawv dawb huv hauv lub tuam tsev. Cia li tsis xav tau mus juggle thiab ua casuistry. Tsis txhob muab ib tug sib npaug zos kos npe rau ntawm lub Koom Txoos Orthodox thiab Patriarch Kirill, nruab nrab ntawm lub Koom Txoos Orthodox thiab cov nom tswv ntawm lub tsev teev ntuj. Orthodox lub tsev teev ntuj - nws tau tsim dhau ib tiam ib tug system ntawm kev ncaj ncees thiab sab ntsuj plig tseem ceeb ntawm cov Lavxias teb sab neeg, seb koj nyiam nws los yog tsis. Thiab tsis txhob nto qaub ncaug rau nws thiab muab tsuj ntiag rau ntawm, los yog muab tso rau kev phem thwmsim mus ntsuam xyuas rau kam rau ua. Lub tsev teev ntuj Orthodox yog heev tolerable, tsis yog raws li ib qho piv txwv rau lwm tus neeg, tiam sis tsis indefinitely. Koj siv rau lub txim txhaum Code - yog cynicism. Tsis muaj ib tug, txawm lub feem ntau tsis ntev los no freak, tsis tuaj mus rau lub siab mus las voos los yog tau txais pw rau ntawm lub ntxa ntawm lawv cov ancestors. Qhov no tiv thaiv tej yam khoom ntawm lub txim txhaum Code, los yog ib tug ntawm cov immutable ncaj ncees cai uas rests (thaum tseem tuav) lub tuam txhab? Kuv yuav coj mus rau lub txim txhaum Code uas yog "ua rau kev ua txhaum kev raug txim?" Tab sis qhov tseeb hais tias lub Lavxias teb sab kev hais plaub ntug system yog nyob rau hauv ib tug yooj yim teeb meem - nws yog muaj tseeb. Tsis nyob rau hauv lub siab hais tias lawv txim "xaus lub Lavxias teb sab kev hais plaub ntug system thiab tawm tsam kev ntseeg siab nyob rau hauv tsoom fwv tsev nyob rau hauv Feem ntau," raws li famously qhia los ntawm Andrei Konchalovsky, thiab hais tias lub system yog tsis npaj txhij rau txaus li cas rau cov cunningly npaj thiab npaj provocation nrog pluag hluas nkauj li pawns. Ntxiv mus, piav ntau zog ntxiv rau ntau tsiv tom ntej. Thiab lub analogy nrog chess kev ua si, thiab yeej-yeej. Txiav txim rau koj tus kheej.

Option 1. Tus tsoom fwv tsis teb thiab cia cia tag nrho cov brakes, vim hais tias muaj yog tsis muaj haum khoom nyob rau hauv lub txim txhaum Code? Heev zoo, ces, koj tseem yuav mus shit (yog vim li cas - ib tug nyias muaj nyias ib sib tham). Thiab qhov kev thov txim yog twb muaj - tsis tau teb hais tias, vim li ntawd nws yog ua tau.

Option 2. Tus tsoom fwv reacted harshly. Txawm zoo dua. Tam sim no koj tau yam xyuam xim tsa lub nqov ntawm tag nrho cov ntawm cov teb chaws Europe - huag, huag, lub arbitrariness ntawm cov tub ceev xwm! Oh, huag - "txom nyem hluas nkauj" nyob rau hauv lub dungeons! Thiab tam sim no cov merzavki - neeg raug txim ntawm conscience thiab tsis muaj hmoo neeg raug ntawm Lavxias teb sab lawlessness. Kauj ruam tom ntej - tau ib lub ntsej muag-down "kab lis kev cai thiab kos duab", cia lub tsis diverge nyob rau hauv lub masses: li ntawd, yog hais tias lawv tau kos npe rau, li ntawd ... Yuav ua li cas yog lub kauj ruam tom ntej? Cem tus mob nyob rau saum lub tsev hais plaub? Zoo, thiab thiaj li nyob rau ... Thiab, tag nrho cov tau ntev siv hom kev kawm ntawm pov tseg. Cia li hais tias - ua nruj ua tsiv rau kev nom kev tswv yog vim li cas, lub arbitrariness ntawm tus neeg, thiab khiav mus rau kev tsis txaus siab mus rau koj tus nyiam West, nyob qhov twg - OSCE. PACE, Amnesty International, dua, lub Strasbourg Court muaj, zoo, rau tag nrho cov txheej tsuas yog tus Hague Tribunal yog tsis txaus. Thaj tu.

Ib zaug ntxiv, tus paub Soviet-era system ntawm pej xeem cov lus teb: "Peb, cov neeg ua hauj lwm ntawm lub Hoobkas, ces ...," "peb, neeg ua hauj lwm ntawm lub teb ntawm lub collective ua liaj ua teb ntawm ib tug tej yam ..." Peb, cov neeg ua hauj lwm ntawm kab lis kev cai thiab kos duab ... ". Qhov loj tshaj plaws uas yog ib tug Rev ntau, li ntawd, respectable looks. Yuav ua li cas yog ib qho tseem ceeb - yog, rau ib tug neeg mus nkaum thiab nug hais tsis nrog ib tug neeg, nrog ib pawg ntawm kev thov. Tab sis nws yuav nthuav kom paub tias qhov twg lub khau pinches. Tom qab tag nrho, leej twg tau xav txog nej tus kheej thiab sau no tsis txaus siab, los yog cov txiv hmab txiv ntoo ntawm collective ua hauj lwm? Ib tug neeg thawj pom tias qhov no kos npe rau? Tab sis lub npe ntawm tus neeg sau los yog cov mastermind qab tag nrho ntawm qhov kev txiav txim, peb tsis yog paub, feem ntau yuav, nws thiab cov signatory yog tsis tam sim no. Tab sis muaj ib tug pab pawg neeg ntawm ib puas thiab tsib caug "nuj nqis", uas laij tso siab rau lub tsev hais plaub, thiab hais tias rau ib co yog vim li cas tsis tau nyob rau hauv tib tus phooj ywg pab nrog ib tug raug txim dab tsi tshwm sim nyob rau hauv lub tuam tsev. Yog vim li cas? Raws li lawv tsis muaj dab tsi tshwj xeeb tshwm sim. Tab sis nws yog tsim nyog los tiv thaiv niaj hnub no.

Heev tsaug hwm kuv thiab Oleg Basilashvili sib hais rau Pushkin, txawm hais tias twb tsis paub xyov yuav ua li cas muaj ntau yam cov ntxhais seev cev nyob rau hauv lub tsev teev ntuj. Nyob rau hauv qhov tseeb, tsib, tsuas yog hais tias ob tug ntawm lawv qhov chaw zapropastilis. Tej zaum nws tsis tau pom tus neeg mob-fated yeeb yam? Nws yog yuav raws li nws yog yuav hais tias nws yuav sawv ntsug ntawm lub rooj ntev zaum, hais tias kuv paub tias tom ntej no mus nws tau hais khov kho zaum Alibasov, tej yam Vasya Oblomov nrog Roma tsiaj nyaum thiab sab laug B-2 rau lub tuam txhab. Rau Ulitskaia lawv tsuas cov neeg raug ntawm ignorance thiab kev phem kev qias. Lawlessness yog qhov tseeb, nws yog peb li. Thiab nws ignorance? Lawv, los yog peb, ib yam nkaus thiab? Mr. Arbatov - cov tib neeg, "nws yog Ameslikas los ntawm Bohemia," hais tias kev ua tau zoo nyob rau hauv lub zoo tib yam lub tsev teev ntuj ua yeeb yam thiab "paub hais tias cov hluas nkauj txav mus li." Tej zaum nws paub, thiab uas lawv yuav tsum tawm mus? Rau Viktyuk txhua yam yog yooj yim - cov heev teeb meem no nws yog kev txhawj xeeb txog lub kawg (ib qho kev nthuav mus kom ze - tsis care txog tus ua kom yuam nyob rau hauv lub tsev teev ntuj, tsis care txog cov kev xav ntawm cov neeg ntseeg, tag nrho cov tsis tu), tab sis muab tso rau "txom nyem hluas nkauj" yog tsis tsim nyog, vim hais tias lawv "cia li hu nkauj zaj nkauj." Tab sis hais tias tsis yog tag nrho cov nyob rau hauv peb kev lis kev cai lub neej. Raws li Manske, qhov teeb meem ntawm tag nrho yog muaj teeb meem, vim hais tias "qhov no zoo ntawm kev txiav txim tau ntev lawm ib tug classic pej xeem kos duab». Shares ntawm ib co zoo? Lub desecration ntawm lub tuam tsev? Mockery ntawm txoj kev ntseeg? Tsis txhob qhia rau Mr. Manskiy lub teb chaws nyob rau hauv uas nws yog ib tug classic thiab qhov chaw uas nws yog xav kom? "Yuav ua li cas yog tam sim no ua nrog Pussy Riot, - nws yog inexplicable thiab irrational, nws yog absurd, nws tsis haum mus rau hauv tej logic, nws yog tsis yooj yim sua kom to taub," - nws hais tias. Thiab qhov tseeb hais tias lawv puas tau nws zoo? Nws tsis yog absurd thiab fits nyob rau hauv koj lub logic? Koj muaj peev xwm nkag siab txog nws? Koj dab tsi kab lis kev cai los yog kos duab muaj? Tab sis hais tias yog tsis yog txhua txhua. Kirill Serebrennikov siab rau convince uas qhov tseeb ua kom muaj kev hais lus nyob rau hauv lub tsev teev ntuj ntawm cov "cov neeg pluag ntxhais" yuav tshaj tawm nyob rau ib lub suab nrov "uas tsis muaj kev tso siab ntawm haiv neeg ROC coj noj coj ua ntawm lub fusion ntawm tsoom fwv thiab lub tsev teev ntuj, lub siab phem kev ntawm lub tsoom fwv thiab lub Koom Txoos, hais txog qhov txaus ntshai schism hauv zej zog, uas xav txhawb kom cov tub ceev xwm ... nws yog nyob rau hauv no yog lawv lub hom phiaj - thiab yuav ua li cas contemporary artists thiab clowns, thiab raws li cov pej xeem thiab patriots. " Tsis muaj ntau, tsis muaj tsawg. Thov txim, tab sis tom qab no nqe vaj lug kub txog kev noj qab nws yog ua tau txawv txawv rau nug. Thiab txij li thaum koj nyob nraum kam them rau cov txuas ntxiv thiab tso siab tau hais tias "lawv yuav mus ntxiv raws li kev ntxias," yog ib qho zoo heev kev xaiv twb paub lawm koj intentions. Tos kom txog thaum lawv tso tawm (los yog, yog hais tias nyob ib tug hurry, tos lwm zoo xws li cov pab pawg neeg), thiab coj lawv ua ke nrog Mr. Manske ncig saib - ua ntej ntawd cia poplyashut nrog lub refrain "Down nrog lub Pope" nyob rau hauv ib pawg ntseeg qhov chaw nyob rau hauv Teb chaws Europe, ces nws yog tau coj lawv cov ib yam dab tsi uas siab nyiam, rau piv txwv, mus rau lub Wailing Wall. Koj yuav cia li las voos nyob rau hauv lub qhib cua, txawm tsis muaj ib tug paab chorus tseem. Yog hais tias nws nca muab tsis tau, nyob ze Mecca. Muaj koj yuav nrhiav tau ib tug lossis loj kev vam meej, txawm tsis muaj dancing. Thaum rov qab los tsev rau Russia (Yog hais tias koj yeej xav txog Russia lawv lub tsev, uas yuav tsis lwj), koj yuav zoo siab rau ua siab zoo thiab siab ntev los ntawm Lavxias teb sab Orthodoxy. Thiab txaus twb yuav taum ib tug ntiv tes nyob rau hauv lub Patriarch thiab nws saib. Nyob rau hauv lub kawg, nws yog tag nrho cov Lavxias teb sab Orthodox lub tsev teev ntuj. Ib yam li cov Pope - lub Koom Txoos Catholic. Koj yuav tsis cam hais tias lub Pope mus taug kev nrog ib tug stick thiab nyob rau hauv rags nrog nws pab yaj, thiab hais tias nws txhais tes saib Suav ntau lawm rau ib tug ob peb duas las.

Thiab lub xeem. Tswv "ntawm kab lis kev cai thiab kos duab." Ua ntej koj kos npe rau dab tsi, txiav txim siab rau lawv tus kheej txhua leej txhua tus uas Russia yog rau koj - lub tsev nyob rau hauv uas nws yog tsis yooj yim sua mus coj ib tug crap, tsis muaj teeb meem li cas peb yog neeg txhaum nws tej zaum yuav, los yog qias neeg tavern, nyob qhov twg puas tsav puas yam yog tau. Yuav ua li cas koj xav txog lub Lavxias teb sab neeg - cov neeg nrog lawv tej kev txhawj xeeb, kev sib tw, kev xyiv fab, kev tu siab, thiab leej twg xav tau kev pab koj tawm kev (tsuas ncaj ncees thiab sincere), los yog nyuj, uas yuav tsum tau noj tej rubbish tias koj tsim, thiab cov uas tau them rau nws. Yuav ua li cas thiab nws sab ntsuj plig thiab kev coj tsis ncaj qhov tseem ceeb koj muaj uas koj yog Orthodox txoj kev ntseeg (yog hais tias koj muaj tus cwj pwm mus rau nws) tsis muaj tej yeeb yam uas tej zaum koj yuav tsis nyiam nws, tab sis tsuas yog - Vera. Nws yog ib feem ntawm koj sab ntsuj plig, los yog lwm tus neeg thoob khib nyiab, uas yuav ua tau ib daim ncuav mog qab zib. Txiav txim siab yog nyob ntawm koj lub koob npe nrov, kev sib hwm, tus cwj pwm raws li cov neeg muaj peev xwm mloog rau ib tug neeg txoj kev xav. Txwv tsis pub - tsis txhob liam kuv, nej cov neeg muaj peev xwm foom phem rau thiab tsis lees paub. Endlessly tso thiab ntaub so nws yuav tsis.

Kwv yees li qhov kev sib tham npaj ib tug Oleg Basilashvili cov hluas nkauj. Tab sis nws muaj nws yuav tau kiag li puas. Thiab koj?